Considered rather scandalous in its time, particularly for showing former child star Hayley Mills' exposed posterior, The Family Way now seems fairly dated and somewhat artificial, both in subject matter and in treatment. It's also a rather uncomfortable blend of sentimental comedy, knockabout farce, and "kitchen sink" realism; trying too hard to contain all of these elements, it fails to satisfy completely. That said, there's a lot to enjoy in Family, starting with the manner in which director Roy Boulting captures the claustrophobic lives endured by the working-class poor. He appreciates the limitations that these characters must endure because of their economic circumstances, but also appreciates the humor that can arise from these circumstances. And he handles the father-son relationship that is the real crux of the picture with great facility. In her first "adult" role, Hayley Mills is charming and appealing without being cloying. Her newly betrothed, the sensitive Hywel Bennett is a good match for her, and both are good company to spend time with. But it is John Mills, as the bridegroom's father, who dominates the film. Loutish, crude, obstinate, and oppressive, he uses his obnoxious qualities to mask his own fears and inadequacies; it is a marvelous piece of acting from a great actor. As his wife, Marjorie Rhodes also makes a strong impression. If Family is a bit obvious in its lessons, it's still worth seeing for John Mills' excellent work. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide